Printed Photos are Permanent: Is Digital?

A collection of just some of my digital storage media from over the years

A collection of just some of my digital storage media from over the years

It’s tough to call those who use a decades-old technology embraced by the majority of the world “early adopters,” but that’s exactly what digital camera owners are.

………………………………………………………….

Memory cards and the inside of a roll of 110mm film

Memory cards and the inside of a roll of 110mm film

Photography has been in existence for more than a century and we know from holding our grandparents’ baby photos that C-prints can withstand the test of time. Can you confidently say the same thing about a hard drive full of digital memories?

Hard drives fail, hacker attacks corrupt clouds and digital technology changes so fast that today’s photographic file standards are already being replaced. Will people even know what to do with a 3.1 megapixel jpg in a few decades? The only true way to ensure that all those precious 1’s and 0’s stay around forever is to print them out and store them safely.

A true photograph is almost alive. The image itself is embedded in the emulsion – the very fibers – of the photographic paper. It’s tangible. It’s something you can hold. A digital file, on the other hand, is an illusion: a trick of light, electricity and motherboards. Sure jpg and RAW pictures are vibrant and easily shared, but when that solar flare sends an electromagnetic pulse towards Earth and fries the world’s circuitry, I’ll be happy to have printed albums of my best work.

A cracked-open roll of Fuji 110 film that I purchased after it was already 10 years expired.

A cracked-open roll of Fuji 110 film that I purchased after it was already 10 years expired.

The best place in America to make high-quality photographic C-prints of your favorite snapshots is Dickerman Prints Photo Lab in San Francisco, where I have the pleasure of working.

In addition to the film inside the 110mm roll, there was a protective black sheet with numbers that correlated to the same negative. That's what the black curly thing is in the background.

In addition to the film inside the 110mm roll, there was a protective black sheet with numbers that correlated to the same negative. That’s what the black curly thing is in the background.

Guardian reporter John Naughton sums it up perfectly:

The reason is that while digital technology has generally been very good for photography as a mass medium, it has also made the resulting imagery much more fragile and impermanent. Of the billions of photographs taken every year, the vast majority exist only as digital files on camera memory cards or on the hard drives of PCs and online backup servers in the internet “cloud”.

In theory – given the right back-up regimes and long-term organizational arrangements – this means that they could, theoretically, endure for a long time. In practice, given the vulnerability of storage technology (all hard disks fail, eventually), the pace at which computing kit becomes obsolete and storage formats change, and the fact that most people’s Facebook accounts die with them, the likelihood is that most of those billions of photographs will not long survive those who took them.

I purchased this 160gb hard drive in computer store in Mumbai, India. Until then, I had never heard of the brand Moserbaer

I purchased this 160gb hard drive in computer store in Mumbai, India. Until then, I had never heard of the brand Moserbaer

My Moserbaer 160gb hard drive has been all over the world with me. I bought it in Mumbai as a backup for my netbook nearly two years ago and it hasn’t let me down yet.

Do YOU trust all your digital images? What is your backup strategy? I would love to hear from you in the comments!

2 Comments

  1. 1
    April 1st, 2012 at 5:31 am

    Granted that hard drives fail, printed copies can also be destroyed in a fire, for example. I think the cloud is a reasonably safe short term backup solution, while the ultimate indefinite archived backup would probably be a DVD or maybe blue-ray disks, and those stored underground in more than 1 location. Analog is less versatile and terribly bulky. I think that enough people are involved with the RAW format, for example, to make sure that at least their old photographs get converted to a would-be modern format. Apocalypse notwithstanding ;-)

    • 1
      April 4th, 2012 at 8:03 am

      Great points! Though, I think a relay of external hard drives is my prefered way to back things up. I have too many old discs that just don’t work anymore and it’s so much easier to keep terabytes of data together on an external.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Latest Related Adventures

What Does Traffic Look Like in the Philippines?

What Does Traffic Look Like in the Philippines?

During my time in the Philippines, I stood or sat on several street corners and filmed the world going by. What I loved most was the contrast between each video.
read more >>

A Photoshop Conundrum: Does No Grate = a Great Photo?

A Photoshop Conundrum: Does No Grate = a Great Photo?

Join me in an exploration of an age-old photographer’s conundrum: “just because you can edit a photo doesn’t always mean you should.”
read more >>

Take a Tour of Tainan, Taiwan – Historic Buildings, Temples & More

Take a Tour of Tainan, Taiwan – Historic Buildings, Temples & More

Explore historic architecture in Tainan, Taiwan, with vibrant photography and a brief history of these famous forts, temples, schools and more.
read more >>

How Tripod Photography Led to an Incredible Local Experience in Taipei

How Tripod Photography Led to an Incredible Local Experience in Taipei

A story of friendship and photography in Taipei, Taiwan, that resulted from my new philosophy of always saying yes to any opportunity that comes my way.
read more >>

The World’s Most Exciting Baseball Game in Taiwan

The World’s Most Exciting Baseball Game in Taiwan

America may have invented baseball, but Taiwan has revolutionized the experience of attending a game. These photos, stories and videos will show you how.
read more >>

Rolling Rice Fields in Sapa, Viet Nam

Rolling Rice Fields in Sapa, Viet Nam

Located high in a northern Viet Nam mountain range, Sapa is a backpacker mecca and home to some of the most stunning rice terraces and fields I have ever seen.
read more >>

A Curvy Casino Dome at Niagara Falls

A Curvy Casino Dome at Niagara Falls

Fine art abstract photography of the inside of a dome. While you are not allowed to take photographs in a casino, there were no rules about pointing my camera upwards in the lobby of the Casino Niagara.
read more >>